The Cowboys play the San Francisco 49ers this week, so in the spirit of rivalry – if not the spirit of total intense hatritude - I am turning this post over to reign of error, who is (saints defend us) an Obama supporter, a Bay Area partisan, and — well — as you will read, someone who is totally and completely misguided in every way. (You can read my post over at his blog now – and you can look at the rest of it, too, especially his deeply irrational opinions about Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.)
Because Curtis got around to his post first, I’m going to try and make this ‘apples to apples’ now and use his admittedly bizarre categories for assessing the lifetime value of each franchise. As for this weekend, I have some friends who think the 49ers could win – the Cowboys have looked terrible and eked out a win last week. I’m not quite that optimistic, though I’d love to be wrong on Sunday.
But, as Curtis asked, which franchise is better? Let’s break it down.
Ownership: The DeBartolos did get kicked out of the league but while they were there they created an environment that made players from around the league want to move to the city by the Bay. Sure, they stretched some laws here and there, but most importantly, Eddie D was the best kind of owner – he threw money around and stayed out of the way. Jerry Jones not only thinks he is the coach, but he meddles almost as much as George Steinbrenner did back in the day. Jerry Jones had a Hall of Fame coach in Jimmy Johnson, and decided he was smart enough that he could not only win without him, he could win with Barry Switzer. Because I’m an understanding man, I’m going to call this one a tie. ADVANTAGE: PUSH
Stadium: Honestly, who cares? Texas Stadium is obviously not so great or the Cowboys wouldn’t be moving out next year. And Candlestick Park is actually an amazing place for a football game. (It sucked for baseball because of the cold, but you expect that in football.) Plus, the Beatles played their last concert there. ADVANTAGE: NINERS
Iconic Coaches: I’m willing to give both Tom Landry and Jimmy Johnson their credit as HoF coaches, and when we are talking ‘icon’ certainly Landry is part of that discussion. But I had to grin when I saw this category from Curtis, because Bill Walsh is not only one of the greatest coaches (and gave up the opportunity for more dollars to go back to Stanford and work with college students), but his influence is greater than anyone else in terms of coaching. Not convinced? Check out this link to see his coaching ‘tree’: Who are the best coaches in football today? Jeff Fisher, Mike Tomlin, Mike Shanahan, Tony Dungy, Andy Reid, Jon Gruden…seriously, can I stop now? This is a no-brainer, slam-dunk win for my boys. ADVANTAGE: NINERS
Iconic Quarterbacks: Joe Montana is the greatest quarterback of all-time. Troy Aikman is not. Not exactly sure what his announcing has to do with anything, but Cool Joe was, and remains, the industry standard. (And Steve Young wasn’t too shabby either.) ADVANTAGE: NINERS
Super Bowls: Frankly, I would have thought this would have been a push, since they each won five rings. But if we want to talk about Super Bowls, isn’t it worth noting that the 49ers never lost a Super Bowl that they got to? 5-0, baby. The Cowboys made it to eight Super Bowls – which is impressive – but choked in three of them. I wouldn’t have mentioned this, but Curtis brought it up. So … ADVANTAGE: NINERS
Organizational Class: Curtis is right when he talks about how awful it was to have Terrell Owens act like a ninny in Irving, dancing on the Cowboys star, etc. But … where does Owens play these days? Oh, that’s right – in Dallas! Add in the history of ‘the white house,’ where all sorts of illegal activity was ignored and/or condoned by the organization for such folks as Michael Irvin and Deion Sanders, and it’s hard to make a claim that the Cowboys have even a lick of class. ADVANTAGE: NINERS.
Did I mention that the 49ers won 10 or more games sixteen years in a row? That’s not only hard to do, it’s never been done by any other team. That they employed the greatest wide receiver of all time in Jerry Rice, the greatest quarterback of all time (Montana) and the greatest safety of all time in Ronnie Lott?
On merit alone, the 49ers should always outproduce the organizationally inferior Cowboys, but games are played on the field, and it’s hard to envision a scenario where the Niners walk all over the ‘Boys like they did the Rams last week. It could be close, and I’ll be crossing my fingers and hoping that good prevails over evil.