Why I Hate Wikipedia
Thursday, June 22nd, 2006So here I am, humble researcher that I am (sometimes), hard at work, doing data entry on a survey project. Since I’m an idiot, I didn’t ask the people filling out the survey to put the county that they work in. It’s a field I’m collecting, though, so I have to figure out what county the respondents are in somehow. I know what city they’re in, but not the county, and I don’t know New Jersey well enough to automatically associate cities with counties. (I mean, I know Trenton is in Mercer County, but you know.)
So I go to Wikipedia. Just about every city in New Jersey has a Wikipedia reference, and just about all those references (I mean, I haven’t looked at all of them) say what county the city is in. I get the information I need, then I go back to the page to close it, and I see that the city is a Walsh Act city.
Well, what does that mean?
So I check it out. And it turns out that there really is a method behind the madness of New Jersey city designations — it’s in the upper right corner if you click on the link. Some places are boroughs, some places are townships — there’s a Raritan Borough and a Raritan Township on US 202, one in Somerset County and one in Hunterdon County. It’s a weird system, but Wikipedia makes sense of it (sorta) and I spent awhile reading up on it, and then found out where I live is a township, and that there’s a city with a similar name in England, and… well, you get the idea.
It is deeply impressive that Wikipedia has that information, deeply disturbing that it might not be quite right, and deeply maddening that it’s there, keeping me from, um, well, data entry. I love Wikipedia because it has lots of good information (at least where it’s reliable), but I hate it because it’s such a timesuck.