So says Time:
Women often tell me it’s important to get more of them elected so they can change the tenor of politics. But that goal has faced some tough choices in the Democratic contest. “He’s the girl in the race,” explains Marie Wilson, head of the White House Project, a nonprofit that helps women move into positions of leadership. “Clinton came out tough; she voted for the war. Obama came out as the person bringing people together and offering messages of hope and reconciliation.”
Although [Minnesota’s Senator Amy] Klobuchar approvingly cites Obama’s practice of feminine politics (”He uses things like the Jeremiah Wright controversy as teachable moments”), she knows as well as anyone that female politicians still face some skepticism. Three months into her Senate tenure, Klobuchar was in an elevator with some aides when a gop colleague entered and gently chided them for taking the Senators-only elevator.
Oh, those nasty mean old Republican Senators, wanting nothing more than to deny women access to the corridors — and the elevators — of power! (Doesn’t say when this happened, but I bet it was Strom Thurmond, and I bet he forgot his eyeglasses that day. Heh.)
Anyway, that ain’t the point. I had not, until right this second thought of Obama as “the girl in the race.” (I suspect this is a self-esteem issue for people who had their self-esteem parked in the Clinton lot, but that’s not the point either.)
The obvious comparison is to the claptrap about Bill Clinton being “the first black president.” That was (and is) claptrap, because the idea was to excuse Clinton’s infidelity, moral poverty, and appetites on his “blackness”, and thereby attributing those particular vices to black America, when they’re just as common everywhere else in this fallen world. And to suggest that Barack Obama is “the first woman president” is about as useless a trope. (Or, to put it another way, as useful as saying that the Rev. Wright affair was a “teaching moment” when all it should have taught anybody was that people who have a history of making loudmouth provocative statements aren’t going to suddenly get less loudmouthed or provocative when they get behind the mike at the National Press Club, and that defending such people is a recipe for trouble.)
But is there any truth to Sen. Klobuchar’s assertion that Obama is using feminine politics to his advantage?
Well, okay. Let’s start with the obvious cheap shot. Google “Barack Obama” and “metrosexual” and you get almost 60,000 hits, for one thing. (The NYT story about Obama’s “body man”, in which he reveals Obama’s taste for steamed broccoli, protein bars and organic tea, as well as his apparent distaste for Budweiser, is instructive here.)
There is all the juvenile swooning over Obama, in part by people who you think would know better (in and out of the media) but apparently do not. This is not to say that this makes Obama feminine or womanly in any way, mind you, but yeesh.
So what we have left is Obama’s hope and reconciliation claptrap, and the dim outlines of his foreign policy. I’d hate to be the one to say that vapid, content-free (and unenforcible) promises to bring America together are in some way “feminine”; it’s perfectly stereotypical to say that men are about conflict and women are about unity. I will admit that there’s something feminine in the idea that all one has to do as President is (let’s say) going to Pyongang and talking to that nasty old Dear Leader and getting him to be a good boy and eat all his vegetables and stop playing with those dirty chunks of plutonium when you don’t know where they’ve been. But that is (God, I hope so) a bit of an oversimplification of Obama’s policies, and I don’t think even the dimmest, most-blinkered tree-hugging Berkeley peacenik (paging Cindy Sheehan) would stoop to that sort of thing if they had real access to power, be they male or female.
I don’t see much that’s girlish about Barack Obama. But then I’m not a girl, and Obama has always been more of a mirror than anything else — or worse, a blank page for people to project their hopes (the Europeans will like us again!) and their fears (that ol’ boy’s a Muslim, I tell you whut). Maybe women see a femininity in Obama that I don’t.
H/T: Althouse.